Introduction
China’s engagement in Africa has grown exponentially in recent decades, encompassing trade, infrastructure investment, and cultural exchange (Alden, 2017). This growing influence has raised concerns about its potential impact on democracy in African nations. While China’s engagement offers certain benefits, such as economic development and infrastructure improvements (Corkin, 2018), there are also potential risks and challenges associated with its expanding footprint. This paper explores the multifaceted nature of China’s influence in Africa, examining both the opportunities and threats it poses to democratic values and institutions, with a particular focus on the role of media and information control.
Motivations Behind China’s Engagement in Africa
China’s interest in shaping the narrative surrounding its activities in Africa is driven by several key motivations:
- Counteracting Negative Portrayals: Beijing seeks to counteract negative portrayals of its engagement in Africa often presented in Western media (French, 2014). These portrayals frequently highlight issues such as neocolonialism, debt-trap diplomacy, and disregard for labour and environmental standards (Taylor, 2020). By establishing its own media presence, China aims to provide an alternative narrative that emphasizes the positive aspects of its involvement, such as infrastructure development, economic cooperation, and cultural exchange (Carmody & Tan, 2021). This is evident in the establishment of state-run media outlets like China Global Television Network (CGTN) and Xinhua News Agency, which produce content tailored to local audiences and often present a more favourable view of China’s activities.
- Soft Power Strategy: China’s engagement is part of its broader soft power strategy (Nye, 2004). By projecting a positive image of itself and its activities in Africa, China aims to enhance its international reputation and strengthen its relationships with African nations (Shambaugh, 2013). This, in turn, can facilitate greater economic and political cooperation, further advancing China’s interests on the continent. The establishment of Confucius Institutes across Africa, which promote Chinese language and culture, is a prime example of China’s soft power diplomacy (Sautman & Hairong, 2010).
- Domestic Propaganda: China’s engagement in Africa also serves a domestic propaganda purpose (Lynch, 2012). By showcasing its achievements in Africa, the Chinese government can bolster its legitimacy at home and garner support for its foreign policy initiatives. This is particularly important in the context of China’s growing global ambitions and its desire to be seen as a responsible and benevolent global power. The extensive coverage of Chinese-led infrastructure projects in state-run media, such as the Addis Ababa-Djibouti railway, serves to highlight China’s contributions to African development and reinforce its image as a reliable partner.
Mechanisms of China’s Influence in Africa
China employs a multi-faceted approach to exert influence in Africa, encompassing economic, political, and cultural dimensions.
Economic Influence
China’s economic influence in Africa is undeniable. It has become the continent’s largest trading partner, surpassing the United States in 2009 (Alden, 2017). China is also a major source of investment in infrastructure projects across Africa through initiatives like the Forum on China-Africa Cooperation (FOCAC) (FOCAC, 2021). While these investments have the potential to stimulate economic growth, concerns remain about debt sustainability and potential economic dependence on China (Corkin, 2022). For example, the construction of the Mombasa-Nairobi Standard Gauge Railway in Kenya, financed and built by Chinese companies, has improved transportation but also raised questions about Kenya’s debt burden (Corkin, 2022).
Political Influence
China’s political influence in Africa has grown alongside its economic engagement. Beijing emphasizes principles of non-interference in domestic affairs and mutual respect for sovereignty, attracting some African leaders who seek an alternative to Western conditionalities (Taylor, 2018). However, this approach has also raised concerns about China’s potential to embolden authoritarian regimes and undermine democratic accountability (Taylor, 2018). China’s close relationship with Zimbabwe under Robert Mugabe, for instance, has been criticized for providing support to a repressive government (Taylor, 2018).
Media and Information Control
China’s strategic use of media and information control is a concerning aspect of its growing influence. China’s state-run media outlets, such as CGTN and Xinhua, have expanded their presence in Africa, offering alternative narratives to Western media coverage (French, 2020). The establishment of CCTV Africa in Nairobi, Kenya, exemplifies China’s strategic media expansion (French, 2020). Additionally, China provides training and resources to African journalists and media organizations, potentially influencing how China is portrayed (French, 2020). Content-sharing agreements and partnerships with African media outlets further amplify China’s messaging (Reporters Without Borders, 2021). The case of Azad Essa, fired for criticizing China, highlights potential risks to press freedom (Reporters Without Borders, 2021). China also utilizes digital platforms like WeChat and TikTok to promote a positive image and engage with African audiences, raising concerns about surveillance, censorship, and disinformation (Cook, 2023).
The Impact on Democratic Values and Institutions
China’s growing influence in Africa presents a complex and nuanced picture with both potential positive and negative impacts on democratic values and institutions.
Potential Benefits
China’s engagement in Africa can contribute to economic development and infrastructure improvements, which are fundamental for creating a stable and prosperous environment often seen as conducive to democracy (Li & Rebolledo, 2021). For instance, the construction of the Addis Ababa-Djibouti Railway, financed by China, has revitalized trade and connectivity in Ethiopia (Li & Rebolledo, 2021). Moreover, China’s emphasis on non-interference in domestic affairs resonates with the principle of sovereignty, allowing African nations autonomy in choosing their development paths (Taylor, 2018).
Potential Risks
Despite these potential benefits, concerns persist regarding China’s influence on democratic values. China’s support for authoritarian regimes and its use of economic leverage to influence political decisions can undermine democratic accountability and weaken institutions (Corkin, 2022). The case of Zambia, where Chinese loans have allegedly been linked to political influence, illustrates these concerns (Corkin, 2022). Additionally, China’s control over information and media, evident in the expansion of state-run outlets like CGTN and Xinhua, can limit the diversity of voices and perspectives, potentially hindering public discourse and dissent (French, 2020).
Varied Impacts Across Africa
The impact of China’s influence on democracy is not uniform across the continent. The specific context of each country, including its political system, economic conditions, and media landscape, significantly shapes the outcome. In countries with weak institutions or a history of authoritarianism, China’s engagement may pose a greater risk to democratic values. Conversely, in countries with stronger institutions and a commitment to democratic principles, the impact may be less pronounced.
Economic and Political Influence: A Double-Edged Sword
China’s economic influence, while contributing to development, can also create economic dependencies that may be exploited for political gain (Corkin, 2022). This is evident in cases like Sri Lanka, where debt to China led to the handover of the Hambantota Port (Corkin, 2022). Simultaneously, China’s political influence, characterized by its emphasis on non-interference, can be viewed positively as respecting sovereignty or negatively as enabling authoritarian tendencies (Taylor, 2018). The relationship with Zimbabwe under Mugabe exemplifies this duality (Taylor, 2018).
Media and Information Control: A Tool for Shaping Narratives
One of the most concerning aspects of China’s growing influence in Africa is its strategic use of media and information control. China’s state-run media outlets, such as CGTN and Xinhua, have expanded their presence in Africa, offering an alternative narrative to Western media coverage (French, 2020). While this can provide a different perspective and challenge Western dominance in the global media landscape, it also raises concerns about potential biases and the dissemination of propaganda. The establishment of CCTV Africa in Nairobi, Kenya, with its focus on promoting a positive image of China and its activities in Africa, is a prime example of China’s strategic media expansion.
China’s engagement with African media goes beyond simply establishing its own outlets. It also provides training and resources to African journalists and media organizations, aiming to shape the narrative surrounding China’s activities on the continent (French, 2020). This can lead to self-censorship among African journalists who may be reluctant to criticize China for fear of losing access to resources or opportunities. The case of Azad Essa, a columnist for South Africa’s Independent Online Media (IOL), who was fired after criticizing China’s treatment of Muslims, highlights the potential risks to press freedom associated with Chinese media influence (Reporters Without Borders, 2021).
Furthermore, China leverages content-sharing agreements and partnerships with African media outlets to amplify its messaging (Reporters Without Borders, 2021). By providing affordable or even free content, China can ensure that its narrative reaches a wider audience and is integrated into local news coverage. This can be particularly effective in countries with limited resources for independent journalism. For instance, Xinhua has signed content-sharing agreements with numerous African media outlets, leading to increased coverage of Chinese perspectives in African media.
In addition to these mechanisms, China also utilizes digital platforms and social media have gained immense popularity in Africa, and Chinese entities are actively using them to promote a positive image of China and its engagement with the continent. However, concerns have been raised about the potential for these platforms to be used for surveillance and censorship, as well as the spread of disinformation and propaganda (Cook, 2023).
Case Studies: A Deeper Dive
Angola
China’s engagement with Angola has been primarily focused on the oil sector, with significant investments in oil exploration and production (Corkin, 2018). This has helped Angola to become one of Africa’s largest oil producers and has provided China with a reliable source of energy. However, concerns have been raised about the lack of transparency in oil deals and the potential for corruption (Corkin, 2018).
In the media landscape, Chinese state-run media outlets have increased their presence in Angola, providing coverage that often aligns with the Angolan government’s perspective (French, 2020). This can limit the diversity of voices and perspectives in the media and hinder critical reporting on issues such as corruption and human rights abuses.
Ghana
China’s engagement with Ghana has been diverse, encompassing trade, investment, and infrastructure development (Large, 2015). Chinese companies have been involved in various projects, including the construction of roads, hospitals, and schools. This engagement has contributed to Ghana’s economic growth and improved social services, but it has also raised concerns about debt sustainability and the potential for Ghana to become economically dependent on China (Large, 2015).
In the media sphere, Chinese state-run media outlets have expanded their presence in Ghana, offering an alternative narrative to Western media coverage (French, 2020). However, there are concerns that this coverage may be biased and may not adequately address issues such as labour rights and environmental impact.
Kenya
China’s engagement with Kenya has been significant, with major investments in infrastructure projects such as the Mombasa-Nairobi Standard Gauge Railway and the Lamu Port-South Sudan-Ethiopia-Transport Corridor (Mohan & Tan-Mullins, 2015). These projects have improved transportation connectivity and have the potential to boost trade and economic growth in the region. However, concerns have been raised about the debt burden associated with these projects and the lack of transparency in contract negotiations (Mohan & Tan-Mullins, 2015).
In the media landscape, Chinese state-run media outlets have expanded their presence in Kenya, offering an alternative narrative to Western media coverage (French, 2020). However, their reach and influence remain limited compared to established Western outlets like the BBC and CNN. Additionally, there have been instances of Kenyan journalists facing pressure from Chinese officials to avoid critical reporting on China, raising concerns about press freedom (Reporters Without Borders, 2023).
Nigeria
China’s engagement with Nigeria has focused on trade, investment, and infrastructure development (Brautigam, 2011). Chinese companies have been involved in various projects, including the construction of railways, roads, and power plants. This engagement has contributed to Nigeria’s economic growth and infrastructure development, but it has also raised concerns about the quality of Chinese projects, labour practices, and environmental impact.
In the media landscape, Chinese state-run media outlets have a limited presence in Nigeria compared to Western and local media. However, there have been instances of Chinese companies sponsoring content in Nigerian media outlets, raising concerns about potential biases and influence.
Mitigating Threats and Harnessing Benefits
China’s expanding influence in Africa has sparked a contentious debate regarding its implications for democratic governance across the continent. While proponents emphasize the potential economic benefits and infrastructure development associated with Chinese engagement, critics raise concerns about the erosion of democratic values and institutions. This multi-faceted issue necessitates a comprehensive examination of China’s diverse strategies and their impact on African nations.
- Enhancing diplomatic engagement: Engaging in robust diplomatic efforts with African governments and civil society organizations to raise awareness about the importance of press freedom and democratic values can be crucial. This can involve advocating for the protection of journalists, supporting media development initiatives, and promoting transparency and accountability in China’s engagement with Africa.
- Building partnerships with African media organizations: Establishing partnerships and collaborations with independent African media outlets can help to strengthen their capacity and resilience. This can involve providing financial and technical assistance, sharing expertise and resources, and promoting cross-cultural exchange and understanding.
- Countering Chinese narratives through strategic communication: Developing and disseminating accurate and compelling narratives about the United States and its engagement with Africa can help to counter Chinese propaganda and disinformation. This can involve highlighting the positive contributions of the United States to African development, promoting democratic values, and exposing the potential risks and challenges associated with China’s influence.
Conclusion
China’s growing influence in Africa is a complex and multifaceted issue with significant implications for the future of democracy on the continent. While China’s engagement offers certain benefits, such as economic development and infrastructure improvements, it also poses potential threats to democratic values and institutions. The strategic use of media and information control by China is a particularly concerning aspect, as it can shape public opinion, influence political decisions, and undermine press freedom.
To mitigate these threats and harness the benefits of China’s engagement, it is crucial to adopt a multi-pronged approach. This includes supporting independent African journalism, promoting media literacy, strengthening democratic institutions, exposing Chinese disinformation, enhancing diplomatic engagement, building partnerships with African media organizations, and countering Chinese narratives through strategic communication. By addressing these challenges proactively and fostering a more transparent and accountable relationship, it is possible to ensure that China’s growing influence in Africa contributes to a more democratic, prosperous, and equitable future for all.
References
Alden, C. (2017). China in Africa. Zed Books.
Brautigam, D. (2011). The Dragon’s Gift: The Real Story of China in Africa. Oxford University Press.
Carmody, P. R., & Tan, A. (2021). China’s media influence in Africa. The International Journal of Press/Politics, 26(1), 142–163.
Cook, J. (2023, March 1). TikTok’s ties to China are a ‘ticking time bomb,’ FCC commissioner warns. Semafor. https://www.semafor.com/article/03/01/2023/tiktoks-ties-to-china-are-a-ticking-time-bomb-fcc-commissioner-warns
Corkin, L. (2018). China’s construction of Africa: A critical analysis of China’s development model in Africa. Routledge.
Corkin, L. (2022). The Belt and Road Initiative and the debt trap diplomacy debate: A critical review. Area Development and Policy, 7(1), 1–17.
FOCAC. (2021). Forum on China-Africa Cooperation Beijing Action Plan (2022–2024). FOCAC. https://www.focac.org/eng/zxxx_1/202202/t20220210_10640775.htm
French, H. W. (2014). China’s second continent: How a million migrants are building a new empire in Africa. Alfred A. Knopf.
French, H. W. (2020, January 28). China’s Africa strategy: More than BRI. Brookings. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/africa-in-focus/2020/01/28/chinas-africa-strategy-more-than-bri/
Large, D. (2015). China’s role in African governance: Assessing the evidence. The South African Institute of International Affairs.
Li, X., & Rebolledo, D. (2021). The Belt and Road Initiative and regional economic cooperation in Africa. Journal of Contemporary China, 30(131), 819–835.
Lynch, D. J. (2012). After the propaganda state: Media, politics, and “thought work” in reformed China. Stanford University Press.
Mohan, G., & Tan-Mullins, M. (2015). China’s “new normal” and its impact on African economies. South African Institute of International Affairs.
Nye, J. S. (2004). Soft power: The means to success in world politics. PublicAffairs.
Reporters Without Borders. (2023). 2023 World Press Freedom Index. https://rsf.org/en/index
Sautman, B., & Hairong, Y. (2010). Friends and interests: China’s distinctive links with Africa. African Affairs, 109(436), 335–359.
Shambaugh, D. (2013). China goes global: The partial power. Oxford University Press.
Taylor, I. (2018). The Forum on China-Africa Cooperation: A Strategic Opportunity for Africa’s Development?. Routledge.
Taylor, I. (2020). China’s new role in Africa. Lynne Rienner Publishers.
